A client participates in an employer's group retirement plan where her savings are held in a group segregated fund. She tells her advisor that her primary objective is to ensure her principal is guaranteed upon death for her heirs, and she assumes her current plan already does this because it has the words 'segregated fund' in its name. How should the advisor guide her based on the recommendation decision tree?
一位客户参加了雇主的团体退休计划,其储蓄持有一只团体分离基金。她告诉代理人,她的首要目标是确保身故时本金得到保障并留给继承人,且她认为现有计划名字里有“分离基金”字样就已经具备这项保障。根据推荐决策树,代理人应如何引导她?
✗ 团体分离基金(group segregated fund)默认不提供身故保证(death benefit guarantee),不能因为名字带“分离基金”就默认它具备个人分离基金的 75% 或 100% 保证结构(产品名称与双口径混淆陷阱)。Incorrect. Group segregated funds carry no death benefit guarantee by default; one cannot assume that because a product has 'segregated fund' in its name it possesses the 75% or 100% guarantee structure of individual segregated funds (product naming and dual-standard confusion trap).
✓ 符合推荐决策树规则:团体分离基金(group segregated fund)默认不提供身故保证;若客户的首要诉求是确保身故本金安全,团体分离基金本身不满足,需另行评估个人分离基金(individual segregated fund)或人寿保险。Correct. In accordance with the recommendation decision tree rules, group segregated funds provide no death benefit guarantee by default; if the client's primary objective is principal protection upon death, the group segregated fund cannot satisfy it, requiring an evaluation of an individual segregated fund or life insurance.
✗ 首套房储蓄账户(FHSA)是针对短期买房等用途核对开户与提款资格的税务容器,并非提供 10 年到期或身故本金保证的保险产品(产品名称与双口径混淆陷阱)。Incorrect. A First Home Savings Account (FHSA) is a tax container for which eligibility to open and withdraw is verified for short-term home purchase goals, not an insurance product providing a 10-year maturity or death benefit principal guarantee (product naming and dual-standard confusion trap).
✗ 候补受保人(contingent annuitant)仅适用于非注册合同(non-registered contract),注册退休计划不可指定候补受保人,且该角色也不创造团体分离基金原本没有的身故本金保证(注册账户分离角色陷阱)。Incorrect. A contingent annuitant can only be named on non-registered contracts; registered retirement plans cannot designate a contingent annuitant, and this role does not create a death benefit principal guarantee that a group segregated fund does not already possess (registered account role splitting trap).
看答案与每个选项的解析Show the answer and why each option is right or wrong
答案Answer:b
换个情境再练一次(同一考点的变式题)Try a variant: same point, new situation
An investor has non-registered savings that she plans to use within two years to purchase a home. An advisor considers recommending an individual segregated fund because of its maturity and death benefit guarantees. Why does this recommendation conflict with the recommendation decision tree?
一位投资者有一笔非注册储蓄,计划在两年内用于买房。代理人考虑到期与身故保证而打算推荐个人分离基金。为什么这一推荐与推荐决策树相冲突?
✗ 非注册账户(non-registered account)完全可以持有个人分离基金并选择 75/75、75/100 或 100/100 担保档位,问题出在时间跨度而非账户限制(注册账户分离角色陷阱)。Incorrect. Non-registered accounts can fully hold individual segregated funds with a choice of 75/75, 75/100, or 100/100 guarantee tiers; the conflict stems from the time horizon rather than account restrictions (registered account role splitting trap).
✗ 个人分离基金(individual segregated fund)无论在注册还是非注册账户中均具备到期与身故担保结构,并非必须在 RRSP 内才有效(产品名称与双口径混淆陷阱)。Incorrect. Individual segregated funds provide maturity and death benefit guarantee structures whether held in registered or non-registered accounts, and do not require being inside an RRSP to be effective (product naming and dual-standard confusion trap).
✗ 给付型年金(payout annuity)适用于已退休或临近退休且需要稳定终身或定期收入的客户,不适用于两年内要提取本金买房的短期资金(产品名称与双口径混淆陷阱)。Incorrect. Payout annuities are designed for clients who are retired or nearing retirement and require stable lifetime or term income, not for short-term funds where principal will be withdrawn within two years to buy a home (product naming and dual-standard confusion trap).
✓ 时间跨度(time horizon)须按资金的真实用途判断:个人分离基金最短 10 年到期,与客户“两年内要用钱买房”直接冲突;合规做法是先比较首套房储蓄账户(FHSA)等税务容器的资格,再配置适合短期用款的现金或短期投资。Correct. The time horizon must be determined by the actual intended use of the funds: individual segregated funds have a minimum 10-year maturity, which directly conflicts with the client needing the money to buy a home within two years; compliant practice is to first evaluate eligibility for tax containers such as an FHSA and then allocate to cash or short-term investments suited for short-term needs.
看答案与每个选项的解析Show the answer and why each option is right or wrong
答案Answer:d