Ethan graduated from university in late 2026 and worked for only one month, earning $4,500 of employment income. His federal tax payable before credits was $630 (14% × $4,500). His basic personal amount of $16,452 generated a tax credit of $2,303.28, which reduced his federal tax payable to zero. In December 2026, Ethan purchased his first home and qualified for the $10,000 home buyers' amount (Line 31270). What is the total federal tax benefit (reduction of tax or cash refund) Ethan receives from claiming the home buyers' amount on his 2026 return?
伊森(Ethan)于 2026 年底大学毕业并仅工作了一个月,获得受雇收入 $4,500。在计入抵免前其联邦应缴税额为 $630(14% × $4,500)。其基本个人金额 $16,452 产生了 $2,303.28 的税收抵免,已将他的联邦应缴税额抵减至零。2026 年 12 月,伊森购买了首套合资格自住房,符合申报 $10,000 首次购房者额(Line 31270)的条件。伊森在其 2026 年报税表上申报该首次购房者额可获得的联邦税收好处(减税或现金退税)是多少?
✗ 错误。此选项误将首次购房者额当成了可退还税收抵免(refundable tax credit)。首次购房者额是非退还抵免,绝不会直接派发现金退税。这落入了「抵免额无税照样能退钱」的典型陷阱。Incorrect. This option mistakenly treats the home buyers' amount as a refundable tax credit. The home buyers' amount is a non-refundable tax credit and never generates a direct cash refund. This falls into the classic trap of assuming non-refundable credits yield cash refunds without tax payable.
✓ 正确。根据第一节制度设计底层逻辑,非退还税收抵免(non-refundable tax credit)的法律效力仅限于将纳税人的当期应缴税额压降至零,不能变为负数,多余的抵免额既不退还现金,也不能结转。由于基本个人金额(basic personal amount, BPA)在法定扣减顺序中排在首位,且已完全将伊森的 $630 联邦税额冲抵至零,因此排在后面的首次购房者额(Line 31270)无法产生任何实际税收减免效果,最终税收价值为 $0。Correct. Under the institutional design principles in Section 1, the legal effect of a non-refundable tax credit is strictly limited to reducing the taxpayer's current-year tax payable to zero; it cannot create a negative balance, and unused credits can neither be refunded in cash nor carried forward. Because the basic personal amount (BPA) ranks first in the statutory claiming order and has already completely eliminated Ethan's $630 federal tax payable, the home buyers' amount (Line 31270) ranked behind it provides zero actual tax savings, resulting in a tax benefit of $0.
✗ 错误。不仅 2026 年联邦抵免率已调整为 14%(而非 15%),而且首次购房者额依法不可向未来年度结转(carry-forward)。Incorrect. In addition to the federal credit rate being reduced to 14% (rather than 15%) for 2026, the home buyers' amount cannot legally be carried forward to future years.
✗ 错误。伊森的联邦税已经被基本个人金额抵为零,首次购房者额无法再抵减任何联邦税;联邦与省税各自按独立表单结算,不存在平分 $630 的规则。Incorrect. Ethan's federal tax liability has already been reduced to zero by the basic personal amount, leaving no tax for the home buyers' amount to offset; federal and provincial taxes are calculated on separate forms, and there is no rule dividing $630 equally between them.
看答案与每个选项的解析Show the answer and why each option is right or wrong
答案Answer:b
换个情境再练一次(同一考点的变式题)Try a variant: same point, new situation
Maya earned $3,800 from part-time work in 2026, generating a pre-credit federal tax of $532 (14% × $3,800). Her basic personal amount credit fully reduced this tax liability to zero. During 2026, Maya also paid $4,000 of qualifying out-of-pocket medical expenses. What is Maya's federal tax savings from claiming the medical expense tax credit on Line 33099 for the 2026 tax year?
玛雅(Maya)在 2026 年兼职赚取了 $3,800,产生抵免前联邦税额 $532(14% × $3,800)。其基本个人金额抵免已将该笔税额完全抵减至零。2026 年内,玛雅还自费支付了 $4,000 的合资格医疗费用。在 2026 税年中,玛雅在 Line 33099 申报医疗费税收抵免所获得的联邦实际节税金额是多少?
✗ 错误。医疗费税收抵免(medical expense tax credit, METC)属于非退还税收抵免,在税额已被清零时无法产生现金退税。Incorrect. The medical expense tax credit (METC) is a non-refundable tax credit and cannot generate a cash refund when tax payable has already been reduced to zero.
✗ 错误。既使用了过期的 15% 折算率,又无视了应缴税额为零的非退还刚性限制。Incorrect. This option uses the expired 15% credit rate and ignores the strict non-refundable limitation when tax payable is zero.
✗ 错误。基本个人金额具有法定优先扣除顺位,且未用完的部分不可结转,无法人为替换给医疗费使用。Incorrect. The basic personal amount has a mandatory statutory priority and any unused portion cannot be carried forward, so it cannot be artificially displaced to make room for medical expenses.
✓ 正确。第一节制度原理明确强调,判断非退还抵免是否有用,第一步永远是核查纳税人当年的应缴税额天花板。玛雅的联邦税已完全被基本个人金额冲抵为零,医疗费抵免(Line 33099)排在法定顺位后方,无法进一步退税或抵扣,因此实际节税效益为 $0。Correct. Section 1 emphasizes that determining whether a non-refundable tax credit provides any benefit begins with verifying the taxpayer's current-year tax payable ceiling. Maya's federal tax has already been completely eliminated by the basic personal amount; because the medical expense credit (Line 33099) sits further down the statutory ordering, it produces zero tax reduction and zero cash refund, yielding $0 in tax savings.
看答案与每个选项的解析Show the answer and why each option is right or wrong
答案Answer:d