Marcus signs an agreement titled 'Independent Contractor Agreement' with a logistics firm. The firm sets his daily shift from 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m., provides the delivery van and pays for all fuel and repairs, prohibits him from hiring helpers or working for other clients, and pays him a fixed hourly wage regardless of delivery volume. If the CRA reviews this arrangement, what is the most likely outcome?
Marcus 与一家物流公司签了一份题为「独立承包商协议」的合同。公司规定他每天早上 8 点到下午 4 点排班,提供送货厢式车并承担全部油费与维修费,禁止他雇助手或为其他客户工作,且不论送货量多少都按固定时薪付酬。如果 CRA 审查这段关系,最可能的结果是什么?
✓ 正确。CRA 按四因素测试(four-factor test / Wiebe Door test:控制、工具、利润机会与亏损风险、整合程度)看经济实质而非合同标题;一旦重新定性为雇佣关系,付款方须补缴未代扣的 CPP、EI 与所得税并承担罚款与利息。Correct. The CRA applies the four-factor test (Wiebe Door test: control, tools, chance of profit and risk of loss, integration) to economic substance, not to the contract title. Once the relationship is recharacterized as employment, the payer must pay the unwithheld CPP, EI and income tax and bears penalties and interest.
✗ 错误。掉入「合同写承包就算自雇」的陷阱:CRA 不看合同怎么写或双方怎么称呼,只看四因素反映的经济实质。Wrong. This falls into the trap "a contract that says contractor means self-employed": the CRA does not look at how the contract is worded or what the parties call it, only at the economic substance shown by the four factors.
✗ 错误。在这套判定下身份不会按税种拆开优待;四项因素全部指向雇员(公司控制工时、提供工具、承担风险、高度整合),整体都会被定性为雇佣。Wrong. Under this test status is not split by tax type for favorable treatment; all four factors point to employee (the firm controls hours, supplies tools, bears the risk, and the worker is fully integrated), so the whole relationship is classified as employment.
✗ 错误。判错身份的代价不对称且主要落在付款方(雇主)头上,付款方要补缴未代扣代缴的 CPP、EI 与所得税及罚息,而非让雇员去补雇主份额。Wrong. The cost of misclassification is asymmetric and falls mainly on the payer (the employer), who must pay the unremitted CPP, EI and income tax plus penalties and interest; the employee is not made to pay the employer share.
看答案与每个选项的解析Show the answer and why each option is right or wrong
答案Answer:a
换个情境再练一次(同一考点的变式题)Try a variant: same point, new situation
Elena provides home daycare services in her own residence. She sets her own operating hours and fee schedule, purchases all toys and food at her own expense, bears the financial loss if enrollment drops, and serves six different families independently. How will the CRA most likely classify Elena under RC4110?
Elena 在自己家里提供家庭日托服务。她自行决定作息时间与收费标准,自费购买所有玩具和餐饮食材,若招不满孩子则自己承担亏损风险,并独立为六个不同家庭提供服务。根据 RC4110 指南,CRA 最可能如何认定 Elena 的身份?
✗ 错误。不能套用职业名称一刀切;CRA 明确指出在自己家里提供日托、自行决定收费与作息、自担场地耗材成本的人通常属于自雇。Wrong. You cannot apply a blanket rule by job title; the CRA states that a person who provides daycare in her own home, sets her own fees and hours and bears her own premises and supply costs is generally self-employed.
✗ 错误。个人服务业务(personal service business)针对的是借公司外壳提供实质雇佣服务的人,Elena 是以个人身份独立自雇经营。Wrong. A personal services business targets people who provide what is in substance employment services through a corporate shell; Elena runs her business independently as an individual.
✓ 正确。对照四因素测试(four-factor test),Elena 自主掌握控制权、自备场地与耗材工具、自担盈亏风险且独立于单一付款方,属于典型的自雇者(self-employed)。Correct. Under the four-factor test, Elena controls her own work, supplies her own premises and supplies, bears the risk of profit and loss, and is independent of any single payer, so she is a classic self-employed person.
✗ 错误。自雇还是雇佣取决于四因素的经济实质,不需要也不靠双方签署放弃代扣义务的书面声明来决定。Wrong. Self-employed vs. employee is decided by the economic substance of the four factors; it does not depend on, and is not determined by, a written statement in which the parties waive withholding obligations.
看答案与每个选项的解析Show the answer and why each option is right or wrong
答案Answer:c