Elena, an architect in Kelowna, incurs an $800 eligible bill for routine dental maintenance. Her personal dental insurance policy has an unused annual deductible of $100 and a co-insurance factor of 80% for routine maintenance, with sufficient annual maximum remaining. How much will the insurer reimburse, and how much must Elena pay out of pocket?
基洛纳的建筑师 Elena 因常规牙科维护产生了一笔 $800 的合资格账单。她的个人牙科保单尚有 $100 的年度免赔额未用完,常规维护的共保比例为 80%,且年度报销上限充足。保险公司将报销多少,Elena 需要自付多少?
✗ 错误(陷阱:免赔额与共保算反顺序)。直接用 $800 × 80% = $640 完全漏掉了第一步先扣除 $100 年度免赔额(deductible)的要求,且受保人除免赔额外还需承担余额 20% 的共保自付部分。Incorrect. Reversing the calculation order of deductible and co-insurance. Multiplying $800 directly by 80% to get $640 completely omits the mandatory first step of deducting the $100 unused annual deductible, and fails to recognize that the insured must pay both the deductible and the 20% co-insurance share on the remaining balance.
✓ 正确。当免赔额(deductible)与共保比例(co-insurance factor)同时出现时,必须严格按“先减后乘”两步计算:先从 $800 中扣除 $100 免赔额得到余额 $700,再由保险公司按 $700 × 80% 报销 $560;Elena 自付部分为 $100 免赔额加上 $700 × 20%($140),合计 $240。Correct. When both a deductible and a co-insurance factor apply, calculations must follow a strict two-step sequence: subtract first, then multiply. First, deduct the $100 annual deductible from the $800 bill to arrive at a $700 balance; the insurer then reimburses 80% of $700, which equals $560. Elena's out-of-pocket cost is the $100 deductible plus her 20% co-insurance share of $140 ($700 * 20%), totaling $240.
✗ 错误(陷阱:忽略共保比例分摊)。扣除 $100 免赔额(deductible)后的 $700 余额并非由保险公司全包,还必须乘以 80% 的共保比例(co-insurance factor),受保人仍需自付 $140。Incorrect. Overlooking the co-insurance cost sharing. The $700 balance remaining after subtracting the $100 deductible is not covered in full by the insurer; it must be multiplied by the 80% co-insurance factor, leaving the insured responsible for the remaining 20% ($140).
✗ 错误(陷阱:忽略成本分担机制)。扩展医疗与牙科保单通过免赔额(deductible)和共保比例(co-insurance factor)控制道德风险,不会对有免赔额与 80% 共保约定的账单全额报销 $800。Incorrect. Ignoring cost-sharing mechanisms. Extended health and dental policies use deductibles and co-insurance factors to mitigate moral hazard and will not reimburse the entire $800 bill when the contract specifies an annual deductible and an 80% co-insurance factor.
看答案与每个选项的解析Show the answer and why each option is right or wrong
答案Answer:b
换个情境再练一次(同一考点的变式题)Try a variant: same point, new situation
Marcus, a graphic designer in Kamloops, submits an $800 eligible claim for a dental crown (major restorative work). His policy has an unused annual deductible of $100, covers routine maintenance at 80%, and covers major restorative work at a 50% co-insurance factor. Why does the insurer apply a 50% co-insurance factor instead of 80% after deducting the $100 deductible from the $800 bill?
坎卢普斯的平面设计师 Marcus 因安装牙冠(重建类项目)提交了一笔 $800 的合资格理赔。他的保单尚有 $100 年度免赔额未用,常规维护共保比例为 80%,重建类项目共保比例为 50%。在从 $800 账单中先扣除 $100 免赔额(余 $700)后,为什么保险公司对余额适用 50% 而非 80% 的共保比例?
✗ 错误(陷阱:公费医保覆盖范围混淆)。省级医保(MSP)不覆盖常规牙科及牙冠、桥体等重建类牙科费用,剩余 50% 须由受保人自己承担。Incorrect. Confusing the scope of provincial healthcare coverage. British Columbia's Medical Services Plan (MSP) does not cover routine dental care or major restorative dental procedures like crowns and bridges; the remaining 50% must be paid out of pocket by the insured.
✗ 错误(陷阱:结算方式与共保比例混淆)。无论是否采用直接结算(direct billing),重建类项目的共保比例(co-insurance factor)均按合同约定的 50% 执行。Incorrect. Confusing the billing method with co-insurance rules. Regardless of whether direct billing is utilized at the dental clinic, the co-insurance factor for major restorative procedures is strictly governed by the contractual 50% rate.
✓ 正确。先从 $800 中扣除 $100 免赔额(deductible)余 $700 后,保险公司对牙冠、桥体这类越贵、越难预测的重建类项目(major restorative)将共保比例(co-insurance factor)从常规维护的 75%–80% 调低至 50%,其底层逻辑是抑制就医道德风险。Correct. After deducting the $100 annual deductible from $800 to leave a $700 balance, the insurer applies a lower 50% co-insurance factor rather than the 75% to 80% routine rate because crowns and bridges represent major restorative work. Setting a lower reimbursement rate on costlier, less predictable procedures is designed to curb moral hazard by increasing the insured's financial participation.
✗ 错误(陷阱:费用标准表与项目分级混淆)。重建类项目适用 50% 共保比例(co-insurance factor)是保单按项目严重度与成本所作的三级分类设计,而非因超出费用标准表(fee schedule)受到处罚。Incorrect. Confusing fee schedule limits with procedure categorization. Applying a 50% co-insurance factor to major restorative work is a structural policy feature based on procedural tier and cost, not a penalty for exceeding the provincial dental fee schedule.
看答案与每个选项的解析Show the answer and why each option is right or wrong
答案Answer:c